As Trump's ICE ramps up its state terror, one might still find one's relatives or neighbors ultimately justifying the campaign. The refrain is usually that they are breaking the rules of proper migration, or that the overall good of the already established American populace benefits by laying down the law of legal migration procedures. Of course, this overlooks the context of migration as a global problem of capitalism as well as the wide variations in migrants statuses- whether as asylum seekers, economic refugees, or people trying to make a quick buck in a wealthy, hegemonic economy. And of course it also overlooks the disturbing saturation of far-right politics which is the main engine of this population control drive- one of the reasons why this deportation campaign is sorting out fascist fascists from more tepid right-wingers (however, it should always be remembered that ICE has always been a bipartisan apparatus of the state). One simple, fairly moderate alternative I came up with to the brutality of ICE deportations is to simply fine 'illegals' until they leave the country voluntarily, instead of traumatizing and endangering them. Because the violent and criminal way that ICE operates is certainly not the only way to deter 'illegal' migration; however, the US border isn't exactly founded upon humane practices.
But forget all these larger contexts throwing into doubt whether or not ICE should be deporting people. Let us try to conceptualize it in a more specific way, in which people you know instinctually might conceptualize it. Because often enough the thinking of this situation falls upon the 'rules' established by 'society' or at the very least notions of what's 'realistic' in this globalized civilization.
America is touted as a proud, Western culture. One whose wealth and power is the result of the innate intelligence and strength of its particular Euro-American ethos and genius (the contributions of immigrants up until the more recent past have been given lip service gratitude in this achievement, for their part). But access to this civilization, as it declines under the threat of 'overpopulation' (inequality/poverty), civilizational instability, as well as climate collapse, must be restricted to a paying customer- the historical 'Land of the Free' is no longer a right, but a privilege. In essence, this 'American civilization' (there is no such thing as a national civilization) is thought to be a self-made 'City on a Hill;' its great wealth was accomplished through its own hard work and ingenuity; and now, after centuries of tolerating the great masses and allowing them to make their way under the protection of our benefaction, the hordes of the world now exceed themselves and will ultimately "poison the blood" and rot us out from the inside.
This conceptualization cannot be true because there is no such thing as the 'national entity' in a globalized world, for one. America is an empire and its imperial penetration, under the guise of multinationals, and overtly through its military and CIA, stirs up and shakes the world from top to bottom. This is where its great wealth and economic proliferation derive from and why the masses of all the nations flock to its doorstep. The centrifugal force of its power induces a centripetal force of the global proletariat, who are dispossessed in that centrifuge. And thus the exclusive 'club' which is bounded by the US border and enforced by its thuggish bouncers, this club which you must be a paying, special customer (https://trumpcard.gov/), is merely the further neoliberalization of the global proletariat- and too many Americans are ready to want to be entitled to be members of this capitalist scheme.
I don't even know what else to say anymore because it doesn't seem writing about it matters. But just look at what civilization is, what humanity is, what the essence of our shared experience on earth is. If you really want to make it hard for immigrants to come to your country, you need to re-configure the international economy, starting with a socially informed and just re-negotiation of NAFTA and other international economic agreements and organizations. But the outdated fossils of racism, xenophobia, and hierarchy continue to prefer to subject other human beings to inhuman treatment, and the ignorance and pettiness of too many people has them buying all too much into that scheme.

